ok gay thread i know, but i need opinions bad, im stuck!

I just bought NHL13 and its TERRIBLE! im taking it back and buying a different game, but now i dont know which one.....


my thoughts are..... Xbox btw

- Skyrim (played it before, only got about 5% done)

- Masseffect 1, 2, and 3- Ok never played MassEffect but i hear its Amazing.......Can anyone shed light on Mass Effect for me
-ive watched yt vids of gameplay, i cant put my finger on it

- Saints Row 3- well looks fun to me, goofy to boot

- FPS- im so lost when it comes to fps, i only play offline so Campaign is HUGE for me (even multiplayer campaign if possible)

- Sims 3- gay but ive always been a sims junky



Please leave your thoughts, points, opinions
Recommend me to any Rad game please, doesnt have to be the ones on this list

I want Playability, not just a once through and done game!


HELP YALLS!