Let's get a ball rolling...

[briden]

so everyone is gonna do the same tricks to get 5 points and we are gonna see those tricks over and over again?

Im sorry, I just dont see the point. Just have people do whatever trick they can come up with and have people vote on the fav trick at each spot. or judges.

1st place, 5 points
2nd place, 3 points,
3rd place, 1 point

Nah man, it's not just getting the tricks, everyone's gotta film and upload everything before the deadline, so nobody would get everything in a full book. My list was just a start, it was gonna be much longer but we ditched the plan early on. We talked at length about judging/voting, but it would only work if everyone submitted their clips anonymously and they were uploaded as such. Everybody's got their favorites and there's no other way to get a true objective opinion.

[SK8ERatWAR]

Nah man, it's not just getting the tricks, everyone's gotta film and upload everything before the deadline, so nobody would get everything in a full book. My list was just a start, it was gonna be much longer but we ditched the plan early on. We talked at length about judging/voting, but it would only work if everyone submitted their clips anonymously and they were uploaded as such. Everybody's got their favorites and there's no other way to get a true objective opinion.

Anonymously would certainly the best way, people always gravitate towards their favourite. Some guys have such distinct filming styles, you can automatically see who that is, so it won't make such a big difference, but I do think it will make people more objective in their opinion.

and are we gonna do weekly edits, just like thrasher? Because I would like to edit those, good ripping music and a fast paced edit, I love to make those!!!
I reaaaheaaheally would love to edit!

[Cerebus_]

I think I would like to be in something like this. I like the anonymous way of doing it. Sounds fun!

[Skatehead]

I'm already crowned King of the Farts.

[Clayfighter]

so everyone is gonna do the same tricks to get 5 points and we are gonna see those tricks over and over again?

Im sorry, I just dont see the point. Just have people do whatever trick they can come up with and have people vote on the fav trick at each spot. or judges.

1st place, 5 points
2nd place, 3 points,
3rd place, 1 point

actually narrowing down a specific trick at spots helps reduce bias. if were all doing whatever, people are just going to go friend picking again ( thats why the skater of the year didnt work). what needs to be done is have each team given specific spots to skate, kind of like how in the real kotr people are skating different cities from each other.

we use the same idea of each specific group of spots having set tricks you have to do as well as having people have to do specific harder or weird trick challenges anywhere in the game world. then you have your biggest, longest etc. aswell has having every team having to get something specific at one "meet up" spot, after that the clips will be judge on what tricks were done from the list, who did the most of those tricks for each team (mvp) and then you have it judge on creativity and style at a spot.

this contest is actually quite easy to set up because we have a perfect guidelines for it. also no CAP, that allows for both xbox and ps3 to compete equally

[Skatehead]

Stinkiest fart down a double set.

[EmmitBrown]

nah i want it to be KOTR...how they do it, but tailored to s3


i don't want just a bunch of made up "own the spot" spots

edit: commented on old post and didnt realize there was another page


that's a good point clay about the ps3/360 regarding CAP

[momadaddy]

how are we going to get strippers in the game?

[EmmitBrown]

how are we going to get strippers in the game?

at the greenscreens

[knexzor]

Sketching like Skelli - Do a trick with the wildest possible sketchy landing
Corey's Challenge - Do a Corey Webster-pop to grind a handrail
Southcity Bound - Hardest line you can possibly muster up
Pawn-o-rama - Do a Pawnluvguitarist-inspired trick or line
Cookiesupporter's challenge - Do a realistic trick or line while going insanely fast
Skinny like Stevland - Gap something and land on a skinny ledge
Signed by the Guy - Do a frontside rock n roll
Like a Chief - Find and skate an ungrindable that hasn't been done

Whadaya think? Feel free to chip in... Just making some suggestions

[Clayfighter]

Sketching like Skelli - Do a trick with the wildest possible sketchy landing
Corey's Challenge - Do a Corey Webster-pop to grind a handrail
Southcity Bound - Hardest line you can possibly muster up
Pawn-o-rama - Do a Pawnluvguitarist-inspired trick or line
Cookiesupporter's challenge - Do a realistic trick or line while going insanely fast
Skinny like Stevland - Gap something and land on a skinny ledge
Signed by the Guy - Do a frontside rock n roll
Like a Chief - Find and skate an ungrindable that hasn't been done

Whadaya think? Feel free to chip in... Just making some suggestions

this is a perfect list, now i have to do mine. i can already see this working

[Skatehead]

Break it like Knex- do a engine bending trick
Drop that Anchors- Land the biggest drop you can find
CLAYflipper 1- double flip to a grind on a handrail
Saunders trippin- Hippyflip in a line

[Clayfighter]

Small Rail

Hard- 20 points

kickflip back tail

kickflip front noseslide

switch back tail

Harder- 30 Points

hurricane

back tail popless shuv

front feeble front 180 out

Hardest- 50 Points

kickflip bs tail popless shuv

biggie front hurricane

switch flip back tail flip out

Fucked up- 150 points

hardflip back noseblunt

[Clayfighter]

Big Rail

Hard- 20 points

kickflip 5050

nollie front feeble

nollie bs noseblunt

Harder- 30 points

sw front feeble

bigflip front noseslide

switch flip bs smith

Hardest- 50 points

nollie front hurricane

switch flip front feeble

airwalk front blunt

Fucked Up- 150 points

caveman darkslide

[Permy]

skatehead's challenges regarding smell are not fair

[Wiltzuh]

Niche this far

Steviester
Snailer
Wiltzer

[Clayfighter]

Ledge

All 50 points

front tail to switch back tail

back smith to tail

crook darkslide

front smith 270

fakie inwardheel switch back tail

switch back crook fakie treflip

switch hardflip front nose

treflip nose to crooks

back blunt to noseblunt

[Ayreon]

and then you have it judge on creativity and style at a spot.

Only thing I was getting at is telling people what tricks to do takes the creativity out of it. There isnt anything creative about it, except maybe what angle you film it.

It makes sense for real life skating cause real life skating is real life, and not a video game and a million times harder.

But whatever floats your boat. I was just thinking just vote for the favorite trick is a more simple and better way to do it. I like the anonymous submission idea. People said with the trick and film style you will be able to tell who it is anyway, but with no names on screen and for the honor of competition, I think people would give unbiased votes for the most part.

I like how Jebo said it. Dont tell them exactly what trick to do. Just a broad scope. "Do a dub grind" is what he said. Not do a "Ollie over the ledge to noseblunt down the other side." Way too specific.


Not that I can even enter cause my ps3 is busted, just trying to share ideas.

good luck getting this going. it would be sick to see a well organized contest happen in the community. Its been awhile since one actually went down

[Roccityroller]

Stinkiest fart down a double set.

just bought some sushi... got this one in the baaaag

Embers speedo party - fastest pool line with a follow cam

[InsideManager]

How could you do a longest grind/powerslide or something without using a CAP? I mean with a CAP you could make a custom little spot with some kind of repeating object that could be counted, might not be too hard to make for both xbox and ps3 if its very basic. But I think a longest powerslide or grind is essential.

[PoppySquidJr]

How could you do a longest grind/powerslide or something without using a CAP? I mean with a CAP you could make a custom little spot with some kind of repeating object that could be counted, might not be too hard to make for both xbox and ps3 if its very basic. But I think a longest powerslide or grind is essential.

The game measures it for ya, you could go for a trust system. I mean, anyone who'd cheat for that is pretty damn low.

[Mark the Sith]

I'm all for keeping the "rules" generic and allowing for some creativity. Far less specific tricks, who wants to watch multiple teams/skaters hit the same spot, doing the same trick over and over and over again. What would separate one from the next?

[Fecal Face]

front smith 270

you would land sideways...haha

I'm in for NOIR if this happens.

I'm all for keeping the "rules" generic and allowing for some creativity. Far less specific tricks, who wants to watch multiple teams/skaters hit the same spot, doing the same trick over and over and over again. What would separate one from the next?

Style. Filming. Creativity.

[Mark the Sith]

That's if the guidelines aren't specific. If it's "Do a kickflip to nose 180 out" where's the style? The creativity?

[Ayreon]

That's if the guidelines aren't specific. If it's "Do a kickflip to nose 180 out" where's the style? The creativity?

no where

[Clayfighter]

i dont really think people understood what i wrote. what i was suggesting is that each team gets a list of different spots in the game. at the those spots there are specific challenges that they have to do as well as people being able to do their own tricks. by having some form of guideline at spots, it allows for a more organized and less biased judgement.

you can still do tricks you want that people can vote on, but by also having a set number of certain tricks or challenges people have to do at a certain spot helps make things fair. if it was just people choosing theyre favorite tricks or styles etc. this whole thing would fall apart because people are biased on here. everyone wants their friend or favorite skater to win, thats why we could never get the skater of the year right, too many people just naming names. but if you set up certain objectives as well as judging on creativity, you get the best of both worlds.

[Mark the Sith]

Just to clarify, and for example, 5150 would get Chan Center and a different set of objectives than say Noir, which would get Observatory and different objectives?

[Clayfighter]

yes, just like how in the real kotr the teams are all going to different cities and getting challenges based on those cities. the idea is that you wouldnt be watching people do the same tricks at the same spot. there would be a set list of tricks each team can complete for points and then there would be spot specific stuff that is different for each team. its helps calculate who has the most points at the end of the thing based on what tricks/ challenges have been done on the univeral list as well as team specific challenges. then you can give out points for non challenge based tricks that you like

[andreas]

here's a fuckin reasonable idea. let's force someone to remake all the spots from a chosen teams KOTR for each fakeskate team and we'll just copy the tricks. fuck dick cheney.

[InsideManager]

Seems like the best way to do it has so far been agreed upon as;

-teams of 4
-each team has a seperate section of PC
-some sem-specific spot/tricks
-some generic do anywhere tricks
-some basic longest/biggest style tricks
-anonymous videos


Seems like we just need to agree upon whether scoring will be voted upon or predetermined or what. I think the best way would be to have polls of the anonymoys team videos, and maybe label what sections of the tricks are for what scoring criteria so we can make easy comparisons between the teams, and then award points for the winners of each category like first place 3 pts, second place 2 pts and third gets 1 pt, then tally it up for a winner. And then of course you can do seperate MVP type voting or whatever.

[Ayreon]

i dont really think people understood what i wrote. what i was suggesting is that each team gets a list of different spots in the game. at the those spots there are specific challenges that they have to do as well as people being able to do their own tricks. by having some form of guideline at spots, it allows for a more organized and less biased judgement.

you can still do tricks you want that people can vote on, but by also having a set number of certain tricks or challenges people have to do at a certain spot helps make things fair. if it was just people choosing theyre favorite tricks or styles etc. this whole thing would fall apart because people are biased on here. everyone wants their friend or favorite skater to win, thats why we could never get the skater of the year right, too many people just naming names. but if you set up certain objectives as well as judging on creativity, you get the best of both worlds.

oh ok. sry I didnt get what you were talking about in the frist place.

[Cerebus_]

Somebody needs to imitate Phelps for the introduction video of all the riders the teams are bringing along.

[Clayfighter]

I think the universal challange list should be based of the challenge types knexzor and Skatehead suggested. Like a big list of basic ideas that we can all attempt, that way we can score those both by getting the challenge done as well as who people thought did it the best. Then with the spot specific challenges, you set certain tricks that have to be landed at those spots.

Then once all the clips are in, the judges calculate which team finished the most challenges with points being added based on style and creativity. Like say one team has the same amount of challenges done, they style points can push them over. This helps make judging easier while still allowing for each team to be creative

[BaphoM3th]

you would land sideways...haha

I'm in for NOIR if this happens.



Style. Filming. Creativity.

Hell yeah me toooo

[Skatehead]

it would be sick to see a well organized contest happen in the community.

Once upon a time ago, there was a Fluckit game of skate....
It never crowned a champ....

[Ayreon]

ahhaa dam eh

[Oddity]

Is there going to be special guests? Because I'd like to be one.

[XImortalDEATHX]

I don't have a team, dammit.

[Dead_Head]

yo fuck it lets just duo this shit imortal

[PoppinSuds]

Im down as well