Those of you still having issues, just comment in magic's thread about ea nation in the daily grind section over at the ea forums, one of ea's admins' fixed my account and it's back to normal for me again.

He said my account wasn't connected to my gamertag, which is why it wasn't working, but that made no sense to me since I never had that issue since the early days of OG when my account that was connected to my gamertag got deleted some how and then some admin fixed it three months later.